America’s Data Centre Backlash: a Warning for India

The backlash against hyperscale data centres in the US midterm elections should be a warning to Indian states competing to host these resource-hungry projects backed by multi-national billionaires. From Andhra Pradesh to Telangana and Maharashtra, governments must confront a question that investment headlines obscure -- who gains from this development, and who pays for it?
By Ajith Pillai in Chennai
Are there lessons in the US midterm elections for Andhra Pradesh, Telangana, Maharashtra, and the other Indian states rolling out the red carpet for big business and their hyper-scale
data centres?
Plenty, if you consider one twin factor that swung the elections in favour of the Democrats: the mushrooming of hyper-scale data centres and the rapid and often forced adoption of AI across the United States.
True, the Iran war, surging inflation, and rising unemployment dominated the news. But beneath those headlines, public anger was simmering over AI and the vast data-centre infrastructure driving its growth. In the run-up to the elections, much of the mainstream media gave this anger scant attention, a predictable blind spot in a US Press long enamoured of Silicon Valley billionaires and their bizarre plans.
However, as the debilitating rout of the Republican Party sank in, it became clear that any post-poll analysis must also include the data centre-AI factor as a crucial force that worked against Trump & Co.
Technology journalist and author Brian Merchant, who has written for the New York Times, Guardian, Slate, Atlantic and Wired, had this to say in his blog:
“Just a year or two ago, their predominance was all but assumed; if anything, the expectation was that they would see expansion along with the platforms they support. Now, all that’s come crashing down spectacularly…. I am talking about data centres, the only entity that may have fared worse than Republicans in the midterms.”
This view was echoed by the Washington Policy Team at Optimal Advisory, an investment and strategic advisory firm founded by Wall Street veterans, Jonathan Feeney and David Schick. Reuters quoted the team’s report: “Data centres went from being a popular economic development tool in 2024 and 2025 to something of a pariah by the time the midterm campaigns gathered steam.”
In a nutshell, before the midterms, data centres became the shorthand for many of the concerns plaguing American society. It all started with environmental activists like Erin Brockovich and Naomi Klein and politicians like Bernie Sanders raising questions. These protests were dismissed by the tech bros and Donald Trump as minor irritants raised by ‘Left-leaning’ activists who were ‘anti-progress.’

But it was not long before more and more people began questioning the wisdom of backing projects that took away their land and exploited electricity and water while adding to severe air pollution, noise pollution and electronic waste. The promised jobs, meanwhile, failed to materialise at a scale that benefited local residents.
What began as a protest against individual projects raised a deeper question that resonated with the larger public: who gains from this kind of development and who is left to bear its costs?
Before the US went to the polls, hyper-scale data centres and AI became a rallying point for those opposed to Trump. An NBC exit poll found 56 per cent of voters felt AI and data centres were “crucial or a major factor” in deciding who they would vote for. Reporters who attended Democratic Party rallies found Republican supporters in the crowd.
Data centres and AI became a bipartisan issue, cutting across party lines and ideologies—and the Republican Party was routed. Even in strongholds such as Texas, Ohio and Michigan, rivals swept to victory after promising to rein in the hyper-scalers.
In India, hyper-scale, AI-compatible data centres are being planned and developed at a frenetic pace. Much of this build-out is concentrated in and around Visakhapatnam (Vizag), a tier-two port city on Andhra Pradesh’s east coast, where mega data centres are planned across 13 locations. There have been widespread protests against the project.
All the big boys have pitched their camps in Vizag, including Google, Meta, OpenAI, Adani, Reliance and TCS.
Their projects, which require substantial amounts of power and water, have collectively been allocated 2,530 acres of land and Rs 71,000 crore in subsidies by the Andhra Pradesh government. These incentives come on top of the central government’s tax holiday, which extends until 2047 for foreign companies setting up these mega facilities in India.
As in the US, the Andhra Pradesh government led by Chandrababu Naidu, a BJP ally, has marketed hyper-scale data centres as a “transformative development tool”. However, farmers who have seen their land being taken away for acquisition without proper consultation are not convinced.
Even among the educated, tech-friendly, the promise of making Andhra Pradesh an international data centre and AI hub is no longer as lucrative as it was when Google announced its $15 billion hyperscale project in collaboration with the Adani group last year.

The slow but growing disillusionment stems from the realisation that mega data centres will do little beyond attracting major foreign investment, which politicians can trumpet as an achievement. The US experience has revealed that no high-end engineering jobs would open up at the hyperscale projects. Indeed, reportedly, the permanent staff required post-construction would be fewer than 150.
And the tech revolution in Vizag, with companies sprouting around the mega data centres, is slowly but surely becoming a mirage as news of a downturn and retrenchment in the IT sector spreads.
As in the US, the establishment has largely dismissed concerns raised by environmentalists and citizens’ groups in the Vizag region as the misguided protests of those “opposed to progress”. But the government’s indifference has not silenced farmers and marginalised communities who have lost land to data centres. They continue to question why their farmlands are being taken over without consultation for projects backed by billionaires who have parachuted into the region with little interest in local welfare.
The heavy, long-term demands these projects will place on water and power supplies are also major concerns across the rural belt.
Some of these concerns found expression in the local body elections earlier this month.
In Bhogapuram village, where the Andhra Pradesh government has earmarked 854.97 acres for Reliance’s $11.5 billion hyperscale data centre, two farmers campaigning against the project scored unexpected victories. Alla Saroja, of the Telaga sub-caste of the Kapu community, and Godla Seshagiri, of the Mala Scheduled Caste, won Wards 2 and 3, respectively.
Contesting as independents, they defeated powerful candidates fielded by the ruling alliance of the Telugu Desam Party (TDP), Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP), and Jana Sena Party (JSP).
Saroja attributed her victory to her opposition to data centres.
“This victory is one for the farmers and one against data centres. It shouldn’t be viewed as a personal victory,” she told The News Minute.
Bhogapuram is a small victory but a significant first step, say the farmers.
According to the Human Rights Forum (HRF), which is active in the campaign against hyper-scale data centres in the Visakhapatnam region, the 13 new facilities would collectively require a continuous power supply of huge 7.9 gigawatts at peak capacity.
For perspective, one gigawatt (GW) equals 1,000 megawatts; enough to meet the annual electricity needs of a mid-sized American city with roughly 750,000 to 850,000 average US homes. Now imagine the hyper-scale data centres planned for the Visakhapatnam region drawing as much power as eight such cities combined.
Where will this additional power come from?
Those opposing the data centres allege that the proposed 3,200 MW coal-fired thermal power plant in the tribal areas of Srikakulam district is intended primarily to power the data centres. The plant is controversial; it was previously stalled after tribal communities protested the encroachment on their land. Now, however, the project has been revived.
The enormous water consumption of these hyper-scale projects is another point of contention. Nara Lokesh, Andhra Pradesh’s IT minister and son of Chief Minister Chandrababu Naidu, has estimated their annual water consumption at 3,500 million cubic feet, or 99.11 billion litres. He says the Polavaram irrigation project will supply this water. He has also argued that water from the Godavari, which would otherwise flow into the sea, could thereby be put to better use.

To assuage public misgivings, hyper-scale data centre executives have outlined measures to reduce water and power consumption. But, given the opacity surrounding the way such facilities operate around the world, and their reluctance to share consumption data, not everyone is convinced.
Data centres have been around for more than two decades. The older ones operated in non-descript buildings, used relatively less power, and attracted little attention. Delhi, for example, has 26 such facilities, together consuming 0.183 gigawatts. Even with a new data centre hub in Delhi-NCR, total consumption would rise to 0.57 gigawatts; still only half the power used by a single hyperscale data centre in Vizag. The contrast gives a sense of just how different the scale of power use can be.
Hyper-scale data centres came into focus after OpenAI launched ChatGPT in November 2022, setting off an AI race that demanded more and more computing power. The old facilities tucked away on street corners could not keep up with that relentless demand. In their place came massive campuses spread across hundreds of acres.
Soon, tech companies were building not just for current needs, but for anticipated future demand. Now, the industry is slowing down in the US, with several states considering moratoriums on new projects and rethinking pending contracts.
Meanwhile, water-deficient Telangana is seeking to match Andhra Pradesh by welcoming hyperscale data centres that will require 5 GW of power and enormous quantities of water. In Thane, outside Mumbai, a hyperscale project is already sparking protests. Other states may also be considering such facilities to attract foreign investment.
The US experience, however, should temper their enthusiasm. Silicon Valley, for its part, will be keen to expand in India as hyperscale data centres find themselves less welcome at home than they were two years ago.
India surely needs to be cautious in its enthusiasm.
Ajith Pillai is Co-Editor independentink.in. A seasoned journalist working in the profession for 40 years, he has reported out of Delhi, Mumbai, Chennai, Andhra Pradesh and Kashmir on a broad spectrum of events related to politics, crime, conflict and social change. He has worked with leading publications, including The Sunday Observer, Indian Post, Pioneer, The Week and India Today, where he headed the Chennai bureau. He was part of the team led by Vinod Mehta that launched Outlook magazine and headed its current affairs section till 2012. Under his watch, Outlook broke several stories that attracted national attention and questioned the government of the day. He has written two books—'Off the Record: Untold Stories from a Reporter’s Diary,’ and a novel, ‘Junkland Journeys’.
Also see by Ajith Pillai:
A $15 billion data cenre in Vizag: So why this secrecy?
A Disaster in the Making: Red Carpet for Hyper-scale Data centres
When Tech Billionaires Come Marching In https://www.independentink.in/post/when-tech-billionaires-come-marching-in AI to the left of them, AI to the right https://www.independentink.in/post/ai-to-the-left-of-them-ai-to-the-right AI is not reliable. Especially in a conflict zone. QED. Hence proved. https://www.independentink.in/post/was-ai-used-to-murder-school-children-in-iran
To err is AI: Bubble burst?
AI tech giants buy books in bulk. Even rare books. Why? To destroy them!