top of page

What is it like to have your safe, creative space taken away from you?

7 minutes ago
11 min read


Satyajit Ray Film and Television Institute, Kolkata: “I was very anxious. The female students felt unsafe. There are crackdowns on protesters, and you know you might get hurt. Here, it felt like we were going to be killed by the goons,” she says. “All of us decided to stay the night. Female students were being followed home. We were being called vile things. Most of us are not from the city. It was scary.”


By Shamya Dasgupta



You live on campus. Except for a few weeks a year, this is where you sleep and wake. It is home to you.

 

Now think of living here in constant fear. Of being denied access to food and water and toilet facilities. Being told that if you raise your voice, you will be kicked out.

 

What is it like to have your safe space taken away from you?

 

“If the vice-chancellor stays, this is not the place for me,” Radhika, a first-year student of the Film Wing at Kolkata’s Satyajit Ray Film and Television Institute (SRFTI), says.

 

The vice-chancellor, Indian Information Service officer Santosh Ajmera, has been the target of the students’ ire at SRFTI for over a month now. This wasn’t the case when the students first rose in protest on September 27, 2026. An organisation called the Akhil Bharatiya Grahak Panchayat (ABGP)—affiliated to the Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh (RSS), the ideological mentors of the Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP)—had not only used the campus auditorium to conduct a programme (which they were within their rights to, having rented the space), but had arrived at the premises well in advance, disrupted film shoots being conducted by the students and, in the words of one of them, “made the female students uncomfortable, taking photos and videos and staring at them”, something other students we spoke to echoed.

 

Ajmera had taken charge just two days prior and was not even present on campus at the time. Since then, though, as the protests have continued and even intensified, Ajmera has gone on the offensive.



The hostel—everything, including the mess—was shut down and the students were given 24 hours to vacate in a notice sent on October 16. They didn’t. 

 

They stayed put and set up a tent in the premises to continue the protest. Ajmera was gheraoed more than once. Six students—the perceived leaders of the protests—were rusticated. Water and electricity were shut off initially but have been restored to an extent since.

 

“A lot of students can’t just go back home,” Ayesha, a first-year student, says. “Arranging tickets in such a hurry… and lots of kids don’t have the means to just go out and rent a flat. It’s inhumane. Everyone doesn’t have the same resources.”

 

In the latest update, a number of students have been issued show-cause notices for one or more reasons, two teaching staff who were on contract and six resource persons have been sacked, some others have been suspended or issued show-cause notices.

 

The notice sent to the students, which we have read, includes clauses like: “unauthorised erection and occupation of a temporary structure on institute premises” (the tent mentioned above); “unauthorised entry and involvement of outsiders in activities in the campus” (Ranjan Palit, the veteran cinematographer, had been invited to conduct a workshop at the tent); “unauthorised electrical connection and use of electricity” (for the tent); “unauthorised organisation and conduct of an event/activity on 27 October 2026”, and so on. The last was about a march around the campus to mark a month of the protests, ending with what the students called a mashaal jaloos.

 

Students at many Indian educational institutions have experienced similar repression in the last few years: Jawaharlal Nehru University (JNU) and Jamia Milia Islamia have pride of place, but putting up stiff competition are University of Hyderabad, Jadavpur University, Aligarh Muslim University, Delhi University, more than one Indian Institute of Technologies (most recently, the protest after the death of Sahil Wakode at IIT Bombay), and so on.

 

The protests are on.

 

Students say they won’t stop till their demands are met.


 

It began with a demand for answers and accountability for what happened on September 27 (the ABGP event, followed by the violence, perpetrated by goons, allegedly of the Akhil Bharatiya Vidyarthi Parishad (ABVP, another RSS-affiliated organisation, and inaction by the police). But, over time, in response to the administration’s actions, the demands have grown: the resignation of the vice-chancellor, removal of police from the premises (a group of them, around fifteen, have been stationed there since October 27), withdrawal of the rustication orders against the six students, among others.

 

“This space must exist. Free-thinking spaces must exist,” Radhika says. “But this might not be that place anymore. Teachers we looked up to are being kicked out. He [the VC] is leaving no ground for negotiation or mediation.”

 

***


National Award-winning film-maker Joshy Joseph was passing by SRFTI in a rickshaw on the evening of September 27 when he saw a lot of activity at and beyond the main gate. He got off and went in to take a look.

 

“Outside, there were lots of police personnel. And some others, in normal clothes, carrying sticks,” Joseph, who divides his time between Kochi and Kolkata, says. “The students were inside and were holding placards, shouting slogans. I strolled around and heard the goons, which is what the people in civilian clothes were, tell the police: ‘give us half-an-hour, we will straighten them out’. The police said nothing to these men with sticks. Thankfully, they didn’t let them go in.”

 

The police are typically on the side of the people who command them, who are aligned with the current establishment, and students are not in a position to command—at SRFTI or anywhere.

 

It was a Sunday.

 

“First-year students don’t have hostels. I was at home, which I share with a batchmate, close to the institute,” Ayesha says. “We saw the messages on the WhatsApp group. One said that the students were being attacked. We were asked to go quickly, since it was a holiday and not many students were there. Strength in numbers. We must have reached at 4.30pm. We were there till 5am or so.”

 

Things had died down well before that, but students—irrespective of gender—leaving the campus were being followed home by unidentified men. At least one student had knife wounds to show from the scuffles inside the campus earlier in the evening. Even two of the faculty members who had tried to intervene had suffered injuries.

 

“When I got there, I saw a bus in the campus. I was told the man who had slashed one of the students with a knife was hiding inside,” Ayesha says. “We stopped the bus from leaving. We wouldn’t let the bus go till the cops came. If it left, he was gone. A policeman came later and the man was put in a police van. The bus left after that. I don’t know if the man was released or if any action was taken. I don’t think so though.”

 

The protests had started by then.

 

“I was very anxious. The female students felt unsafe. There are crackdowns on protesters, and you know you might get hurt. Here, it felt like we were going to be killed by the goons,” Ayesha says. “All of us decided to stay the night. Female students were being followed home. We were being called vile things. Most of us are not from the city. It was scary.”

 

“The moment a mob gathers, if there are women in the forefront, there are gestures and words from the men against them,” Radhika says. “We have received online threats: ‘women like this should be raped’. It’s the playbook. If you are a woman, it can seem more intrusive. It can feel gendered. But what I feel is that these thugs don’t consider us as people anymore.”

 

At one point, the students had shut the main gate. That was before the police had reached. It meant the police were stuck outside and some of the goons were still inside.



 

“Some of them tried to enter the library and trash it but the librarian refused to let them in,” Ayesha says. “The faculty was there helping students. Most of our teachers are brilliant and care for us. They stayed with us.” She also says that the first member of the administration that made an appearance, registrar Deepak Kumar, turned up only at around 9.30pm. By then, things had calmed down to a large extent.

 

***

 

That was September 27, 2026.

 

The Dean’s Council rusticated the six students on October 15. One of the things they were charged with was “manhandling” the vice-chancellor. According to a member of the SRFTI administration we spoke to, one of those students kicked the vice-chancellor; all of them abused Ajmera in “filthy language”. The academic council, it appears, recommended the rustications. “We had no choice.”

 

And on October 16, academic activities were suspended and students were asked to vacate the hostel rooms “within 24 hours”.

 

Not all the rusticated students have left. Not everyone has vacated their hostel rooms. 

 

Some did, students who were leaving for the Durga Puja holidays anyway.

 

“It’s not possible to go back within 24 hours. I live in Kerala. How can I get a ticket in the festive season so quickly,” Jijo, a second-year student, says. “I was not planning to go home. It’s normal for students to stay here during the holidays. The institute never shuts down. Something is always happening here. The theatre is supposed to be open. We watch films. No classes of course.”

 

Jijo, like some of the others, doesn’t live on campus since he did not get a hostel. He was supposed to, though, but that’s around when the issue began and it hasn’t happened.

 

“I was here [when the students were asked to leave, on October 16],” he says. “The mess was already closed. Some of the water filters hadn’t been working and had not been repaired, and we had to go to the new [women’s] hostel to get water.”

 

He says the water supply had been poor for a while, but it has improved of late. The mess has been closed since the vacation was announced. “Some students cook their meals at the tent,” Radhika says. The ones that stay outside the campus eat at home. Some of them bring things for their comrades.

 

Jijo has been living on campus since trouble began. “With a friend, in a hostel room.”

 

And leaving the campus as ordered wasn’t a guarantee of anything. “A friend who went to Kerala after September 27 has got two show-cause notices,” two students mention. “He has been in Kerala all through.”


 

Curiously, as Radhika says, “We had to sign a bond when we joined saying that we won’t ask for hostel facilities.” Basically, the institute has expanded its courses in recent years. Some of the older students that haven’t completed their courses remain in the hostels. Space has been a problem. Students are told not to demand hostel accommodation.

 

“The bonds were signed in good faith since we expected hostel space after joining, which was verbally promised, we didn’t know the implications,” Radhika says. “Students come from all parts of the country. There is a language barrier. When we look for flats nearly, there is open caste and other discrimination. Outright. Also gender bias. Societies won’t accommodate single women or even men.”

 

The recent developments have meant that some of the students have had trouble with their landlords for being “troublemakers”.

 

 

***

 

“Waiting, protesting… we are hoping something good is going to come out of this,” Ayesha says. The students are in a limbo. “We have each other. We have been trying to have classes, workshops. With external faculty. There is fear too, because the VC is vindictive.” Incidentally, the vice-chancellor is currently on leave for Diwali.

 

The Blue Banyan Collective, which helps organise cultural events, has been helping the students, including contacting Palit to conduct a workshop. The screening committee of the SRFTI Students’ Union has arranged for filmmakers Payal Kapadia, Vikramaditya Motwane, Don Palathara, Chaitanya Tamhane, Anand Gandhi and Vinay Shukla, among others, to have their films screened at the tent and then interact online with the students.

 

Support has come from many quarters. Whether it be social media posts from the likes of Kapadia, Naseeruddin Shah, Ashish Avikunthak and Anuparna Roy, or filmmaker Indranil Roy Chowdhury and actor Riddhi Sen going to the campus and talking to students.

 

Palit, who has taken classes at SRFTI in the past, said in a video circulated by the students’ union, “I was very saddened to hear that two members of the faculty who were kind of on the side of the students, their contracts have been terminated. And I think that is really horrible because for the faculty to just interact with students and be moral support, how can the vice-chancellor throw them out of their jobs? […] It is very shocking and is completely fascist.”

 

As things stand, there is an “atmosphere of fear”, second-year student Arunabha says. Fear not just about what the vice-chancellor might do next, but of what the students’ futures hold.

 

The students have carried on for almost 50 days now, but it has been tough. There are policemen in the premises strutting about, interrupting free movement of the students. Even security guards within the premises have been asked to take pictures and videos of students on their mobile phones, almost as an additional layer of security. For the management.

 

“A friend saw a guard recording her with his phone. We confronted him, but he refused to show us the footage. We found out that the directive had come from the VC,” Radhika says. “It’s not just one security guard. They are being asked to do this. In a residential campus. It’s a surveillance state here. In some ways, we live with the security guards. They act in our films and we eat together, chat, interact. It’s not their fault, and we have spoken to them and they are ashamed.”

 

The police, incidentally, have also been seen taking pictures and videos, the students say.

 

 


***



The students won’t budge.

 

 Ajmera doesn’t look like he will either.

 

“We will fight until our demands are met,” Kamal, a student, says. “The VC must go and the rustications must be revoked and the police must be removed from the campus. There is no room for negotiations.”

 

At the same time, another student, Joy, says, “Unofficially we have heard that if this goes on for six months, he [the VC] will let it.”

 

There is now a legal case on. Jhuma Sen, a Calcutta High Court lawyer who is representing the students, has been quoted in sections of the media saying that the expulsions were done without hearing the students’ version and that the actions of the SRFTI management (read Ajmera) were not legally tenable.

 

All of this, understandably, takes an emotional toll on the students, many of whom might be politically aware but are not politicised the way students at certain other institutions around the country are. Even the SRFTI Students’ Union, for the most part, works as a go-between for the students and the management. Yes, there are occasional sit-in protests, but nothing nearly as big as what has happened over the past five weeks.

 

“Anxious, tired, scared,” Ayesha says of how the students are faring. “The VC has been sending emails to parents. That’s below the belt. Even if we want to continue, once parents find out, many of us will be stopped from coming back to the institute. My parents, for example, have no problem with me being part of a protest, but they will worry.”

 



There are students that are worried about their future—not just the ones that have been rusticated. There are students who can go home, but won’t simply, because they know their parents wouldn’t want them to return. There are students who vow that they will carry on the fight, but it takes enormous strength of will to make that happen.

 

As things stand, classes are suspended till December 11 this year.

 

In the middle of all this, the students have found new friends, found comfort and strength in each other, been together, united for a cause.

 

“Some students initially might have been Right-wing supporters, which is fine, but everyone still stood together against the Right-wing goons,” says Ayesha. “That was beautiful. Kept me going, honestly. That was very motivating.”



Great filmmaker Satyajit Ray's statue overlooks a protest meeting of students at the SRFTI campus.

 


* Names of students have been changed to protect their identities

 

Shamya Dasgupta is a sports journalist by profession, currently working as Deputy Editor with ESPNcricinfo , and a cinema enthusiast. He's the author of Don't Disturb the Dead: The Story of the Ramsay Brothers (2017), and two books on sports, Bhiwani Junction: The Untold Story of Boxing in India (2012) and Cricket Changed My Life: Stories of Hope and Despair from the IPL and Elsewhere (2014). He translated Mahasweta Devi's Laayl-e Aasmaner Aayna into the English (Mirror of the Darkest Night, 2019). He has recently edited a volume of essays on Ritwik Ghatak by eminent writers, filmmakers, academics, novelists, poets, among others: Unmechanical: Ritwik Ghatak in 50 Fragments, published by Westland.  He lives and works in Bengaluru.


Photos courtesy of SRFTI Students' Union

 


Subscribe to Our Free Newsletter

  • White Facebook Icon
  • Instagram
  • Twitter

© 2035 by TheHours. Powered and secured by Wix

bottom of page