top of page

US mid-term polls: Who will govern the capitalists?

11 minutes ago
7 min read

Photo courtresy of ajplus / Instagram
Photo courtresy of ajplus / Instagram

The Democrats’ victory: According to an Associated Press survey, approximately six in ten voters considered the decision to use force against Iran wrong. The high cost of living, housing, healthcare, and government corruption, were more widely cited. 

By Narendra Pachkhédé in London  



The Democrats’ victory in the American midterm elections of November 3, 2026, has brought together two questions that have rarely been adequately considered within the same political argument: the authority to conduct war and the authority to govern economic life. 

 

The eight-month war against Iran has imposed costs extending far beyond the battlefield, contributing to rising energy prices and public anger over the Trump administration’s conduct of foreign policy.

 

It has also raised constitutional questions about executive power and Congress’s responsibility for decisions involving military force. According to an Associated Press survey, approximately six in ten voters considered the decision to use force against Iran wrong, although only about a third described the war as crucial to their congressional vote.

 

The cost of living and government corruption were more widely cited. 

 

These concerns have converged in an electorate confronting the consequences of decisions made through institutions over which it exercises limited influence. The Democrats have acquired congressional power through that discontent, but the result tells us little about whether Americans have embraced a particular alternative to the economic policies of the Trump administration. What it does reveal is a growing tension between the extraordinary powers exercised by government and its apparent inability to provide lasting economic security.

 

The familiar argument between market freedom and government intervention offers an inadequate explanation. The American economy has never operated independently of public authority. Corporations possess rights established through law, creditors rely upon enforceable claims, financial institutions operate through publicly regulated systems, and private investment frequently depends upon infrastructure, subsidies and protections supplied by government.

 

Yet, the decisions made within these organisations can remain largely beyond the influence of the people affected by them. A corporation may close a factory, relocate production or restructure employment while remaining entirely within its legal rights. Workers and communities must then absorb the consequences, often turning to elected officials for assistance after the decision has already been made.

 

The question is therefore how economic power has been distributed, whose interests it protects, who bears the consequences of its exercise and whether a democratic government can alter those arrangements.

 

The war has made this problem unusually visible.

 

The American State can mobilise extraordinary resources for military operations, impose sanctions, reorganise trade relationships and sustain public commitments with consequences extending across generations. Its capacity to act is considerable, although the division of responsibility between the presidency and Congress remains contested.

 

Meanwhile, proposals to strengthen healthcare, protect employment or extend social provision are regularly confronted by arguments about fiscal restraint and the need to preserve conditions favourable to investment. The legal and political considerations governing these decisions are different, but the contrast requires an explanation.

 

Government acts through priorities that determine whose claims are accommodated and whose burdens are treated as unavoidable. The extent of governmental power cannot be understood independently of the purposes for which it is used.

 

Hakeem Jeffries has identified affordability, accountability and constitutional government as priorities for the incoming Democratic majority. In his November 4 letter to House Democrats, he proposed reversing Medicaid cuts, restoring food assistance, extending Affordable Care Act subsidies, removing Trump’s tariffs and ending the Iran war. 

 

Senate Democratic leader Chuck Schumer has similarly emphasised affordability while warning against treating the electoral victory as an unrestricted mandate for the party’s entire programme. Senator Chris Van Hollen has argued that ending the war, confronting corruption and addressing the material difficulties of working Americans must proceed together.

 

These priorities reflect a coalition whose members agree upon the need to challenge the administration but hold different views about how extensively American economic arrangements should be changed.

 

That disagreement is consequential. Abdul El-Sayed’s advocacy of Medicare for All and higher taxation on extreme wealth belongs to a different conception of economic reform from the more moderate approaches associated with other incoming Democrats. Sherrod Brown’s return to the Senate brings the experience of industrial decline and organised labour into a congressional coalition that also contains strong advocates of market competition and private investment.

 


The Democrats will possess the power to investigate the administration, set legislative priorities and use Congress’s control over public spending. They will also face a Republican president with the power to veto legislation. Their victory therefore opens a dispute over the direction of economic policy under circumstances in which political power remains divided.

 

The immediate temptation will be to judge the new Congress by the amount of relief it can deliver. That is understandable when households are struggling with healthcare, housing, energy and food costs.

 

But the legislation that provides relief also determines what businesses can be required to do, what protections citizens can claim and the conditions under which public resources support private enterprise. A subsidy can make an essential service affordable while leaving considerable control with the companies providing it. Regulation can change the responsibilities of those companies without changing their ownership. Labour protections can alter the balance of power between employers and workers even when investment remains privately controlled.

 

The Democrats’ economic programme should be examined through these differences, because each represents a distinct answer to the question of who is entitled to make decisions affecting other people’s lives.

 

Image courtesy of nycdsa / Instagram
Image courtesy of nycdsa / Instagram


An Unsettled Economic Majority

 

The division between moderate and progressive Democrats is commonly presented as a disagreement about the size of government. Their actual programmes reveal a more complicated argument about economic organisation.

 

In February, the New Democrat Coalition published an Affordability Agenda proposing reforms to housing, healthcare, energy, competition and family support. It called for the construction of four million homes over a decade, changes to zoning and permitting, increased housing tax credits, a higher minimum wage and stronger protections against medical debt.

 

The Congressional Progressive Caucus’s programme, announced in April, addressed many of the same costs while placing greater emphasis upon public provision, labour rights and restrictions on corporate practices. Its proposals included measures against companies using personal information and artificial intelligence to set prices, lower prescription drug costs and expanded access to healthcare. The caucus also supports a longer-term transition towards Medicare for All.

 

Both programmes envisage substantial government action. Their differences concern the means through which that action would occur, the discretion private organisations would retain and the rights that citizens might acquire.

 

Healthcare provides an immediate illustration. In its post-election analysis, KFF found that 49 per cent of voters trusted Democrats more than Republicans to handle healthcare, compared with 30 per cent who preferred Republicans. Fifty-four per cent said the administration’s policies had worsened their healthcare costs.

 

These figures give Democrats a strong political reason to prioritise restoring insurance subsidies and reversing Medicaid reductions. Yet the immediate objective of making treatment affordable leaves important decisions unresolved.

 

Public subsidies can help households purchase private insurance while preserving the commercial organisation of coverage. Insurers continue to administer benefits and operate within a system whose rules determine the treatment patients can obtain and the expenses they must bear. Regulation has already limited some of that discretion through coverage requirements and consumer protections.

 

A greater public role in financing can also weaken the dependence of healthcare upon employment, improving the circumstances under which workers change jobs or negotiate with employers. The character of reform depends upon the protections provided, the requirements placed upon insurers and the alternatives available to patients.

 

A more extensive public programme would reorganise financing, although it would still require decisions about hospitals, medical labour, providers and the allocation of resources. The political choice cannot be settled simply by asking whether healthcare should be public or private. The existing American system combines public expenditure, private administration, employer-based coverage and extensive regulation.

 

The question for Congress is which decisions should remain within commercial discretion and which should become enforceable public duties. The Democrats can agree that Americans should pay less for healthcare while disagreeing over who should possess the power to determine the cost, availability and conditions of treatment. Their legislation will disclose these commitments more clearly than their shared campaign language.


The same problem appears in the infrastructure supporting private investment. The New Democrats have proposed protecting households from increased electricity-grid costs associated with manufacturing and data-centre development. The issue may appear technical, but its consequences are substantial. A business requires electricity and transmission infrastructure to expand. Utilities and regulators must determine how much of the resulting expenditure should be recovered from the business and how much distributed across existing customers.

 

A decision favourable to new investment may impose costs upon households that receive few direct benefits from it. Alternatively, requiring companies to bear more of those costs may influence where and how they invest. The dispute concerns the conditions under which private enterprise may draw upon collectively maintained resources. Congress and public regulators already have a role in determining those conditions. Their decisions can influence the economic advantages available to investors as well as the expenses borne by people who have little say over the investment itself.

 

Housing introduces another distribution of power. Restrictions on development can preserve the advantages enjoyed by existing property owners while limiting the supply available to tenants and first-time buyers. Removing some restrictions may increase construction, but the affordability of the resulting housing also depends upon land values, financing, rents and the treatment of housing as an investment asset. Public tax credits can encourage development while transferring public resources to private owners.

 

Rental protections and publicly supported housing may strengthen the position of households otherwise exposed to market conditions they cannot influence. There are legitimate disagreements over the effectiveness and unintended consequences of these approaches. Their political significance lies in the relationships they create between property owners, tenants, developers, lenders and government.

These examples complicate the customary separation between market-oriented reform and more ambitious public provision. Greater competition can challenge established corporate privileges, particularly in industries dominated by a small number of firms. Public expenditure can expand access to essential services while preserving significant commercial power. 

 

Labour legislation may constrain managerial discretion without transferring ownership. The formal distinction between public and private activity tells us surprisingly little about how decisions are actually made. What counts is the content of the rules, the protections they establish and the ability of affected people to enforce them.

 

The new Congress will have to make such choices without a settled agreement about the ultimate direction of reform.

 


To be continued…

Editor’s Note: This is part one of a series analysing mid-term polls, the resounding victory of the Democrats,  and the future prospects of citizens and the political economy in America,

 

Narendra Pachkhédé is a critic and writer who splits his time between Toronto, London and Geneva. His latest book is ‘Form as History – When History No Longer Requires Us’ (Daraja Press, 2026). This article appeared in Naked Punch Review (https://nakedpunch.com/who-governs-capitalism/) on November 11, 2026.

 

 

 

 

 
 

Subscribe to Our Free Newsletter

  • White Facebook Icon
  • Instagram
  • Twitter

© 2035 by TheHours. Powered and secured by Wix

bottom of page